The MEGA META MESS 

 

The Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal 

 adopted 1989  & entered into force on 5 May 1992

The Meta Strips Project :

The idea of the project in itself is  excellent.

 To recycle is to regenerate.

With the phenomenal growth in technology and its demands, especially in the developed world, has come about a mountain of scrap.

Some of this scrap contains very valuable copper. This copper can be salvaged and recycled.  The scrap is cheap. Nobody in the developed world wants it. In fact, they want to dump it.  There are rich dividends to be obtained by salvaging valuable copper from valueless scrap.

Pure, simple, smart economics !

The Question

If it is so simple & smart, why is Goa the "beneficiary" of such largesse? 

One has to ask this question as there are few who have given to Goa, thus far,  without there being a very special reason ! Many have taken from Goa and returned precious little back to Goa. Precious little.

The Answer :  

It is European scrap which will return pure metal to Europe and leave some money and a lot of scrap toxin behind in Goa !

A humble suggestion :  

All ye brethren All over the world .... Please recycle your own waste in your own yard . Goa has  no need for any more of your toxic stuff .

Background :

Goa's natural state being ripped apartThere is a tiny little State on the west Coast of India called Goa. It is famous for its beaches, music, cuisine, hospitality and incredible beauty. It is also known for a placid set of inhabitants who are quite happy to go through the normal rigors of life and then return to their country homes to relax  while enjoying a delicious meal of fish or mutton xacuti or vindaloo along with the odd glass of wine, whiskey, beer or the native caju feni.

The Goans, as the residents of Goa are known, have gone about their lives in the villages for centuries, quite oblivious to what happens in the corridors of power in the capital city called Panjim, Pangim, Panaji  or Ponnje.

Masters have come and Masters have gone. Each one has inflicted some form of harm or another, on Goans. Regardless of the feelings or views of the Goan masses, the political masters sitting in the capital city in tandem with the wishes of 'money bags'  did as they saw fit.

Regard for  popular wishes, feelings or even the environment have never been given any consideration beyond lip-service. Several projects were undertaken and completed much against the advice of environmental groups and popular wishes.

The popular refrains were " The environmental groups are only politically motivated trouble makers. The people ?  They are   Goans, Remember? What do they know? "

Goa's green status being threatenedWith most of the media in the control of big business, the valiant environmentalists have been effectively marginalized and the few brave and upright journalists who decided to stand up,  continue to face the force of the 'editorial muscle'. What is indeed surprising is that the bold and the 'fed up with the nonsense' have risked their lives and their livelihood to confront the injustice meted out by  "money bags".

Over the past 30 years, the powers that be were able to engineer the placement of at least two environmentally disastrous projects right in and through  the hearts and heartland of Goa and Goans, and that too, with relative panache. One is the toxin spewing Zuari Agro Chemicals and  the other is the environment disturbing Konkan Railway. If the political machinations had been right, there might even have been a nuclear plant bang in the middle of Goa, courtesy the late Goa ironman, Dayanand Bandodkar.

So, when time came for the META STRIPS project, Goa was the natural choice.

It is after all the land of "Chalta Hai" (it's OK),  "Zalaach Pahije"  (It must happen) and "Sossegado" (Ah! life is breeze-easy). This project apparently was  destined initially  for the western India State of Gujarat,  but was diverted to  Sancoale, Goa after a brief  "sigh"  at the neighbouring village of  Verna.

Sancoale, Goa: 

The factory site was established on the Sancoale plateau. The village of Sancoale lies between two major towns of Goa i.e. Vasco da Gama and Margao. The villages of Verna and Cortalim are adjoining. The factory site is located in the midst of a cluster of villages, the nearest residence being just 160 metres away. 

Under the plant  site lies porous, laterite stone. Any effluent released by the plant has a very good opportunity of seeping into the ground water table .

The Application Process : 

First, an advertisement sponsored by GIDC ( Goa Industrial Development Corporation ) appears in the local newspapers. This advertisement is seen to "invite" the META principals to set up shop in Goa.

Step two, on September 7, 1996,   a company by the name of Nasik Wires Ltd applies for a license to operate in Goa.  

Curiously enough, a day before the company actually  applied for this license, the Goa State Pollution Control Board convened a meeting to discuss the application.

That the so-called Goa Pollution Control Board could call for such a meeting when the company had not even applied for license with Director of Industries (the principal licensing authority) remains but one smoking gun in this terribly underhand and corrupt attempt to hoodwink Goa and its people.

Approval for this project was granted by then Goa Chief Minister Pratapsingh Rane and Industries Minister Luizinho Faleiro.  A new company Meta Strips was given a No Objection Certificate to open the said plant based upon the approval granted by Rane and Faleiro.

Were the people of Sancoale given all the information and asked for any input?  No! 

Was the scientific community at Goa University asked for input? No!

Were environmental groups in Goa taken into confidence and asked for their input? No!

Did the Goa Government ask its Public Works Department if there would be enough water and electricity to supply this company? No!

Does this whole process look suspicious?  Tell us what you think!

In a State where it takes enormous amount of time and 'weight' to get a single permission to get electricity connection for a private home, this speed of process in approving a factory of this magnitude is astonishing to say the least. Perhaps, it ought not to be

In a State where the average household suffers from chronic power cuts and water shortages, this approval is mind boggling. Perhaps, it ought not to be.

As expected, the people of Goa revolted under the leadership of AMCAC.  The Goa Government played the usual song: wait, meet, have an one man inquiry etc and finally allowed the factory to proceed.

TGF condemns the presence of a factory in a residential site. Enough pollution and degradation has taken place in Goa. Enough.

Such autocracy was expected under the dictatorship of the Portuguese dictator Dr. Antonio Salazar. That was one more reason we got rid of him.

In a democracy, it should be left to the people to accept or decline the presence of any factory, base, bombing range, prison etc in their backyard. It is the business of the government to have OPEN town hall meetings where everyone can make their case and debate it.

This did not happen in Sancoale.....did it?

To those who argue that the Government sometimes has to look at the greater good of the State, and that employment is the major consideration that the State has to take into account, please vide the following:

http://www.garynull.com/Documents/erf/pvc_dioxin_enough_is_enough.htm

PVC & Dioxin: Enough Is Enough 

Shintech, the Japanese chemical company, has been trying since 1996 to locate 3 factories and an incinerator next to homes and schools in the small community of Convent in southern Louisiana(USA)

Convent residents and other Louisiana activists are fighting the proposed industrial complex, which would manufacture 1.1 billion pounds of PVC plastic (better know as "vinyl") each year. 

They argue that Louisiana authorities would violate federal civil rights laws if they licensed the Shintech plant in a predominantly African-American community where pollution is already making people sick. The outcome of this civil rights battle will set important legal precedents. 

There is no reason to believe that Shintech will bring economic prosperity to the Convent area. The community already has a variety of high-tech toxic industries, yet 40% of its residents live below the poverty line.

==

Enough Said !

TGF

May 9, 2001

The Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal 

 adopted 1989  & entered into force on 5 May 1992

 

read all about: Hi Tech Canadian Toxic Trash

 

Return to The Goan Forum

Post a response                                                                     

The Goan Forum©

a Boa Vista-Bahamas presentation

The views expressed on this site are ONLY those of the authors. Please contact the authors if you wish to reproduce any of the posts or The Goan Forum to comment upon their content.